States High court

Morbi Bridge Tragedy: Govt Leaves Decision to Grant Bail to Oreva Group CMD with High Court

The Gujarat government on Wednesday stated that the decision to grant bail to Oreva Group CMD Jaysukh Patel in the Morbi bridge collapse case of October 2022 would be left to the discretion of the Gujarat High Court.

Justice Divyesh Joshi reserved his order following submissions from the petitioner, relatives of the victims, and the government.

The Morbi bridge collapse occurred on October 30, 2022, in Gujarat, resulting in the tragic deaths of 135 individuals, and injuring 56.

Jaysukh Patel was implicated in the criminal case due to his company’s responsibility for maintaining and operating the British-era bridge.

During the court proceedings, Additional Advocate General Mitesh Amin informed the court that the investigator had reported on September 18 that all aspects of the incident had been thoroughly investigated.

Additional Advocate General Mitesh Amin emphasized that the court should exercise discretion in deciding a bail application, citing Supreme Court judgments provided by both the victim and applicant sides.

The accused in the case include Oreva chairman and managing director Jaysukh Patel, two managers of his company, two sub-contractors involved in bridge repairs, three security guards, and two ticket booking clerks.

While six of them were released on bail, Jaysukh Patel, the manager, and the two proprietors of Devprakash Solutions, the firm responsible for repairs, remain in judicial custody.

The accused face charges under Indian Penal Code sections 304 (culpable homicide not amounting to murder), 336 (act endangering human life), and 338 (causing grievous hurt by doing rash or negligent acts).

Additional Advocate General Mitesh Amin highlighted factors the court may consider when deciding the bail plea, including the duration of the petitioner’s imprisonment, completion of the investigation, the number of witnesses, the accused’s status as a businessman, and the absence of any risk of absconding.

Additional Advocate General Mitesh Amin concluded by stating, “Ultimately it is the discretion of the honourable court. I leave it to the discretion of the honourable court.”

Victims have filed applications seeking the addition of certain offenses, and Amin noted that, as charges were yet to be framed, either side could apply for adding or removing offenses.

Nirupam Nanavaty, Jaysukh Patel’s lawyer, argued that a large crowd rushing onto the bridge contributed to its collapse, and even if Oreva Group had deficiencies in bridge maintenance, they were unaware of the massive crowd gathering on that evening.

Nirupam Nanavaty urged the court to consider Jaysukh Patel’s tenure in custody, asserting that he was not required to be further incarcerated.

Nirupam Nanavaty also contended against charging the accused under section 304 of the IPC.

In opposition to bail for Jaysukh Patel, victims’ lawyer Rahul Sharma expressed concern about potential tampering with witness records and emphasized the gravity of the accused’s charges.

Nunnem Gangte

Recent Posts

Supreme Court Says “Marriage Is Relationship Built On Mutual Trust, Companionship”

The Supreme Court has upheld a decision by the Madras High Court granting a divorce…

1 day ago

Delhi HC Grants Anticipatory Bail To Lawyer In Brother’s Criminal Case

The Delhi High Court has granted transit anticipatory bail to a lawyer whose brother is…

2 days ago

Justice Madan B Lokur Appointed As Chairperson of UN Internal Justice Council

Former Supreme Court Justice Madan B Lokur has been recently named the chairperson of the…

2 days ago

Karnataka High Court Directs NLSIU To Implement 0.5% Reservation For Transgender Persons

The Karnataka High Court has recently directed the National Law School of India University (NLSIU)…

2 days ago

Allahabad HC Directs UP Vigilance To Investigate Himalayan Cooperative Housing Land Issue

The Allahabad High Court has directed the Uttar Pradesh Vigilance Department to investigate the Himalayan…

2 days ago

Allahabad HC Grants Stay On Mohammed Zubair’s Arrest In Religious Enmity Case

The Allahabad High Court on Friday issued an order staying the arrest of Mohammed Zubair,…

2 days ago