In a recent dialogue during the Third Law and Constitution event, Justice Mudgal outlined his vision for improving sports governance in India. He emphasized key reforms, including youth development, legal frameworks, arbitration, and modernizing processes, to create a transparent and effective sports ecosystem.
The evolution of sports governance in India has been a long journey marked by notable successes and persistent challenges. While India has produced world-class athletes in cricket, badminton, and boxing, other sports like football, basketball, and tennis continue to face hurdles stemming from ineffective governance. At the forefront of discussions on these issues is Justice Mukul Mudgal, an influential figure who has consistently advocated for systemic reforms in sports management.
The Current State of Sports Governance
India’s sports governance has historically been fragmented, with cricket emerging as the dominant exception. The Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) is globally recognized as one of the most powerful and well-funded sports bodies. However, the governance of other sports has lagged behind, marked by inefficiencies and mismanagement.
Justice Mudgal stressed the need for these federations to adopt reforms that align with international standards. He pointed out that measures like term limits for office-bearers, mandatory audits, and third-party disclosure practices are essential for fostering accountability and better administration.
“BCCI may be the most powerful, but other sports bodies must also undergo reform to match up to international standards,” he remarked.
Youth Development: The Foundation for Success
Justice Mudgal underscored the importance of nurturing young talent to elevate India’s status on the global sports stage. Reflecting on India’s near-semifinal finish at the 1956 Melbourne Olympics in football, he lamented the sport’s decline in subsequent decades. Despite recent improvements, India’s current FIFA ranking of 134 highlights the need for sustained investment in youth development programs.
Mudgal advocated for establishing football academies and improving infrastructure, emphasizing the sport’s accessibility. As a low-cost sport requiring minimal equipment, football offers vast potential for engaging and empowering India’s youth.
“Football is the world’s most popular sport and the cheapest to play. If we invest in youth development, we can turn the tide,” he stated.
The Role of Legal Reforms
Justice Mudgal highlighted the need for robust legal frameworks to support better governance in Indian sports. Many federations, he observed, operate without proper checks and balances, leading to inefficiencies and stagnation.
The introduction of a comprehensive sports law, as suggested by a committee he chaired, remains in limbo. Such a law would enforce term limits for office-bearers and require mandatory audits, ensuring that leadership positions are not monopolized and that resources are managed effectively.
Streamlining Arbitration and Dispute Resolution
Sports disputes often involve athletes, federations, and sponsors, necessitating swift and fair resolutions. Justice Mudgal advocated for improving the arbitration process by restricting hearings to specific times during the week, reducing delays, and avoiding unnecessary adjournments.
“By restricting arbitration hearings to Monday through Friday and ensuring specific time slots, we can speed up dispute resolution and avoid unnecessary delays,” he suggested.
He also emphasized the need to modernize plea bargaining in sports-related cases, a system he believes is underutilized. By streamlining this process, minor offenses could be resolved efficiently, reducing the burden on courts and allowing more focus on enhancing the sporting ecosystem.
Learning from Global Best Practices
Justice Mudgal’s involvement in FIFA’s governance committee, where he collaborates with representatives from 11 countries, provides valuable insights into international standards. He believes India must integrate these practices to improve its governance frameworks and set an example for other nations.
“India has immense potential. With the right reforms and focus on youth, we can make our mark in the world of sports once again,” he asserted.
A Roadmap for the Future
The path to transforming sports governance in India is fraught with challenges but not insurmountable. Justice Mudgal’s recommendations—spanning youth development, legal reforms, and arbitration—offer a clear roadmap for progress.
The future of Indian sports depends on collaborative efforts by the government, sports federations, and legal professionals to create transparent, efficient, and inclusive governance structures. By prioritizing reforms and empowering young athletes, India can reclaim its lost glory and rise as a global sporting powerhouse.
As Justice Mudgal aptly observed, the evolution of sports governance is about more than winning medals—it’s about creating a system that embodies fairness, transparency, and accountability, paving the way for a brighter future in Indian sports.
Read More: India’s Secular Future at Stake: Debating the Places of Worship Act, 1991 | Legally Speaking
