Categories: Other Courts

Delhi HC Seeks Centre’s Response On PIL Challenging Constitutional Validity Of Solitary Confinement

The Delhi High Court on Tuesday issued notice to the Union Ministries of Home Affairs (MHA) and Law and Justice on a PIL challenging the constitutional validity of provisions related to solitary confinement.

A Division Bench led by Chief Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Subramonium Prasad ordered the respondents to file their responses within six weeks. The matter is listed for further hearing on May 23, 2023.

Advocate Harsh Vibhore Singhal filed a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) challenging Sections 73 and 74 (both related to solitary confinement) of the IPC as well as several sections of the Prisons Act, 1894.

Singhal argued that the term “solitary confinement” is neither defined in the IPC nor in the Prisons Act. According to the plea, this is an additional punishment as well as an arbitrary judicial and police power with no nexus to the sentence.

The petition argued, “It is a blatant violation of the law, and no court can presume that just because a heinous crime was committed, a convict also deserves to be kept in solitary confinement. That solitary confinement is a venomous lethal sting of a veritable scorpion; it is a sadistic, barbaric, and inhuman practise that confines prisoners in dingy malodorous dungeons by abusive, coercive, and obstreperous prison officials for even minor prison infractions such as feigning illness, squabbling over food or access to toilets, being indolent or even talking-back.”

It further added that solitary confinement is inhumane because it isolates an inmate from sensory, visual, and social society, and that even the Supreme Court has stated that such punishment should be used only in the rarest of rare circumstances.

Meera Verma

Recent Posts

“Don’t Get Carried Away By ‘WhatsApp University’ Messages”: SC Justice KV Viswanathan

Supreme Court Justice KV Viswanathan on Saturday raised concerns about the increasing spread of misinformation,…

23 minutes ago

NGT Notes ‘Chaotic Aftermath’ Of Diljit Concert, Directs Immediate Restoration Of JLN Stadium

The National Green Tribunal has recently directed immediate restoration of the Jawaharlal Nehru Stadium following…

53 minutes ago

Delhi HC Confutes BSNL’s Decision To Rescind Contract With IT Company

The Delhi High Court has recently annulled BSNL’s decision to cancel a purchase order it…

1 hour ago

“Delhi’s Illegal Hotel Borewell Sealing Drive To Continue”: Authorities Informs NGT

Authorities in Delhi have on Saturday informed the National Green Tribunal that the operation to…

2 hours ago

India Inaugurates First Constitution Museum At O.P. Jindal Global University

India on November 23, 2024 has celebrated the inauguration of its first Constitution Museum at…

2 hours ago

1984 Anti-Sikh Riots Case: Delhi Court Summons 2 Former Police Officials

The Rouse Avenue Court on Saturday summoned 2 former police officials, Dharam Chandrasekar and Ravi…

2 hours ago