Other Courts

JK and Ladakh HC Sets Criteria for Compulsory Retirement of Government Employees

The Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh High Court has recently clarified the criteria for compulsory retirement of government employees under the J&K Civil Services Regulations.

It held that a decision to prematurely retire an employee cannot be solely based on committee recommendations. Instead, the competent authority must independently form a bona fide opinion that the retirement is in the institution’s interest.

In a Letters Patent Appeal, the bench overturned the earlier order of the Single Judge, which had quashed the petitioner’s compulsory retirement. The impugned order, issued under Article 226(2) of the Jammu and Kashmir Civil Services Regulations, had prematurely retired the petitioner.

The bench analyzed the concept of compulsory retirement, emphasizing the need to eliminate inefficiency, corruption, dishonesty, and deadwood from government service. It reiterated that a bona fide opinion by the competent authority is essential for justifying compulsory retirement.

The judgment highlighted the employer’s obligation to produce relevant documents when an order is challenged as arbitrary or mala fide under Article 226. The court ruled that the service record of a government servant should not be considered privileged and inaccessible to the court.

Regarding involvement in criminal cases as a basis for compulsory retirement, the bench clarified that mere involvement does not establish guilt. The nature of the offense and the circumstances of each case should be carefully considered.

In this case, the court noted that the petitioner’s reputation had not been officially questioned, as no adverse remarks were found in the Annual Performance Reports. Moreover, the petitioner had been acquitted of the charges. Therefore, the court concluded that the petitioner’s compulsory retirement based solely on the registration of a criminal case was unwarranted.

Consequently, the State’s appeal was dismissed.

Nunnem Gangte

Recent Posts

Supreme Court Says “Marriage Is Relationship Built On Mutual Trust, Companionship”

The Supreme Court has upheld a decision by the Madras High Court granting a divorce…

2 days ago

Delhi HC Grants Anticipatory Bail To Lawyer In Brother’s Criminal Case

The Delhi High Court has granted transit anticipatory bail to a lawyer whose brother is…

2 days ago

Justice Madan B Lokur Appointed As Chairperson of UN Internal Justice Council

Former Supreme Court Justice Madan B Lokur has been recently named the chairperson of the…

2 days ago

Karnataka High Court Directs NLSIU To Implement 0.5% Reservation For Transgender Persons

The Karnataka High Court has recently directed the National Law School of India University (NLSIU)…

2 days ago

Allahabad HC Directs UP Vigilance To Investigate Himalayan Cooperative Housing Land Issue

The Allahabad High Court has directed the Uttar Pradesh Vigilance Department to investigate the Himalayan…

2 days ago

Allahabad HC Grants Stay On Mohammed Zubair’s Arrest In Religious Enmity Case

The Allahabad High Court on Friday issued an order staying the arrest of Mohammed Zubair,…

2 days ago