Categories: Other Courts

No Relief To IRS Officer Who Supported Sri-Lankan Tamils

The Madras High Court recently dismissed a plea filed by an Indian Revenue Services (IRS) officer challenging disciplinary measures taken against him after he went on hunger strike in solidarity of Sri Lankan Tamils.

A bench of Justice VM Velumani and Justice R Hemalatha said that the “Conduct Rules” for government employees explicitly forbade them from belonging to any political party or “openly expressing” support or opposition to government policy.

Therefore, as a government servant , Balamurugan should have shown restraint, according to the bench.

“The Conduct Rules of any Government servant clearly prohibit being a member of any political party or openly expressing support or opposing any Government Policies. It is true that the petitioner showed his empathy towards his fellow Srilankan Tamil crisis, but as a Government servant he ought to have restrained himself in expressing his personal opinion. He has not denied the misconduct,” the division bench stated.

In February 2009, Balamurugan, an Assistant Commissioner of Central Excise, went on a seven-day hunger strike and wrote to the President of the Indian National Congress, criticising the party’s positions on the Indo-Sri Lanka Peace Agreement.

In February 2009, the Revenue Department suspended him, and in June 2009, he was issued a charge memo.

He was accused on two counts; one for taking an unlawful leave of absence in 2007, and the other for his hunger strike and letter to Congress President.

An investigation was launched, charges were filed against Balamurugan, and he faced a wage cut as part of the process. He requested for voluntary retirement in 2009, but it was denied. He then appealed the disciplinary proceeding to the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), which confirmed the decision of wage reduction in 2021.

Balamurugan subsequently petitioned the High Court, saying that he was the victim of a “witch hunt,” and requesting that the CAT ruling be overturned.

The Central government’s counsel, Senior Panel Counsel V Sundareswaran opposed Balamurgan’s plea, claiming that the petitioner had violated the Conduct Guidelines, which automatically triggered substantial penalty actions.

Advocate Sundareswaran stated that despite being a government employee, Balamurugan had engaged in politics, participated in demonstrations and strikes, and also criticised government policy, which could not be regarded lightly.

The bench decided that the disciplinary proceedings against Balamurugan had been carried out in conformity with the law. It was also highlighted that Balamurugan had never contested the accusations against him, but was instead voicing concerns about the method used.

Hence, the bench dismissed the plea, stating that Balamurugan had “erred” in asserting that there had been irregularities in the process and that CAT had been “correct in holding that the petitioner’s appeal had no substance.”

 

Nunnem Gangte

Recent Posts

Gulmarg Fashion Show: Srinagar Court To Hear Case Against Organizers On April 8

A Srinagar court has scheduled a hearing for April 8, 2025, in connection with the…

2 days ago

Gold Smuggling Case: Kannada Actress Ranya Rao Moves Sessions Court For Bail

Kannada actress Ranya Rao, arrested last week in connection with a gold smuggling case, has…

2 days ago

“Advocates Can appear In Confiscation Proceedings Under Forest Act”: MP High Court

The Madhya Pradesh High Court ruled that advocates can represent clients in confiscation cases under…

2 days ago

Cement Prices Are Likely To Increase Because Of New Mineral Tax By States: Report

Cement prices across various states are expected to increase following a Supreme Court ruling that…

2 days ago

“Plaint Against Teacher By Parent, Student: First Enquiry, Then Arrest”: Kerala HC

The Kerala High Court has laid down new guidelines to protect educators from hasty arrests…

2 days ago

SC Ruling Paves Way For Visually Impaired Judges; Yavnika Shares Her Experience

Supreme Court recently opened up the doors for visually impaired candidates in judiciary by striking…

4 days ago