‘Today It Is Bilkis, Tomorrow It Could Be Anyone’: SC Questions Gujarat Govt Decision For Premature Release Of Convicts In Bilkis Bano Case

The Supreme Court on Tuesday questioned the Gujarat government on its decision to allow the early release of 11 life convicts in the Bilkis Bano case.

When considering remission in such heinous crimes impacting society at large, the bench of Justices KM Joseph and BV Nagarathna stated that the power must be exercised while keeping public interest in mind.

It further added that just because the Central government agreed with the State’s choice does not imply the State is not compelled to apply its mind.

“The question is whether the government used its mind, what material formed the basis of its decision, etc (Judicial) order ordering convicts to serve the rest of their natural lives in prison. (They were) released by executive order. Today it is this lady (Bilkis). It maybe you or me tomorrow. There must be objective criteria. If you don’t give us a reason, we’ll draw our own conclusions,” Justice Joseph observed.

The bench was hearing petitions challenging the inmates’ premature release, including one brought by the victim herself. On March 27, it issued notices in the pleas.

“The law has been laid down in Venkata Reddy’s case, where his remission as a ‘good Congressman’ was overturned. Even though power exists, the yardstick is extremely high. There must also be reasons,” Justice Joseph told the respondents, before ordering them to produce the files. Respondents are also required to file counter-affidavits by May 1.

The matter has now been rescheduled for May 2, when the bench will also rule on a review petition filed by the government against the court’s March 27 judgement.

“We will decide whether to file one by Monday,” ASG SV Raju, who represented both the Centre and the Gujarat government, told the bench.

 

Isha Das

Recent Posts

Centre Opposes Ex-Judges Panel To Monitor Stubble Burning In SC

The Centre on Friday opposed a proposal in the Supreme Court to form a committee…

5 hours ago

“It’s A Celebration For Us”: Delhi HC Bar Association Felicitates CJI Sanjiv Khanna

The Delhi High Court Bar Association on Friday honored Chief Justice of India Justice Sanjiv…

5 hours ago

International Criminal Court Issues Arrest Warrant For Israeli PM Netanyahu

The International Criminal Court has recently issued arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu,…

6 hours ago

Cal HC Stays Demolition Of Illegal Constructions In WB’s Mandarmoni

The Calcutta High Court on Friday granted an interim stay on the demolition of alleged…

6 hours ago

SC To Pass Order On Pleas To Efface Words ‘Secular’, ‘Socialist’ From Preamble

The Supreme Court on Friday announced that it would deliver its order on November 25…

7 hours ago

Air Pollution: SC Questions Delhi Govt On Truck Entry Amid GRAP-4 Restrictions

The Supreme Court raised concerns on Friday about the "drastic" consequences of the GRAP Stage…

7 hours ago