Supreme Court

Apex Court: Can’t End Private Contract Without Sufficient Reason

While presiding over a case, the Chief Justice of India asked how a private contract could be ended without giving a reason, especially when a private person makes investments after bagging a contract and has a reasonable expectation of getting a return.

The Facts of the Case

On May 25, 2023, a division bench of the high court confirmed the decision of a single judge bench, which had approved the cancellation of a contract awarded to a firm led by Subodh Kumar Singh Rathour.

The firm had won a contract to maintain two underpasses on the Eastern Metropolitan Bypass in Kolkata for 10 years. As part of this agreement, the firm was permitted to display advertisements both inside and above the underpasses, for which it needed to carry out some construction work.

However, on February 7, 2023, the Kolkata Metropolitan Development Authority (KMDA) terminated the contract. Subodh Kumar Singh Rathore had moved to the Supreme Court to appeal against the order pronounced by the Calcutta High Court.

Court’s Proceedings

Senior advocate Rakesh Dwivedi, representing the Kolkata Metropolitan Development Authority (KMDA), informed the Supreme Court that a new contract has been awarded to a different party. He suggested that Rathour could be compensated accordingly.

Senior advocate Shyam Divan, representing Rathour, expressed his desire to avoid any disruption in the maintenance activities at the underpasses. However, he argued that the communication through which the contract was canceled should be invalidated.

The Chief Justice, referring to the case’s details, pointed out that no reason was provided for the cancellation of the contract. Though the court reserved its judgment, it held that contracts awarding work to private parties should not be cancelled without assigning reasons.

Read More: Supreme Court, Delhi High Court, States High Court, Other Courts, International

Hemansh Tandon

Recent Posts

Pune Porsche Case: SC Rejects Anticipatory Bail To Father Of Minor Driver’s Friend

The Supreme Court on Tuesday denied bail to Arunkumar Devnath Singh, whose son is a…

5 mins ago

SC Dumps Plea Against Quashing LOC For Sushant Singh Rajput’s Ex-House Help

The Supreme Court on Tuesday dismissed the Centre's appeal against a Bombay High Court order…

25 mins ago

Rape Case: SC Issues Notice On Ex-Army Officer’s Plea For Quashing Charge sheet

The Supreme Court on Tuesday has agreed to review a plea from retired Army Captain…

1 hour ago

Chhattisgarh NAN Scam: FIR Against 2 Retired IAS Officers, Former AG

The Chhattisgarh Anti-Corruption Bureau on Tuesday has registered a case against 2 retired IAS officers…

1 hour ago

“Not All Private Properties Can Be Acquired Under Article 39(b)”: SC

A 9-judge bench of the Supreme Court delivered a significant ruling on Tuesday regarding the…

2 hours ago

Karnataka HC Notices CM On Plea To Transfer MUDA Case To CBI

The Karnataka High Court on Tuesday has issued a notice to Chief Minister Siddaramaiah and…

3 hours ago