Supreme Court

Supreme Court Disapproves Centre’s condition for additional borrowing Consent for Kerala

The Supreme Court, on Wednesday disapproved Union Government’s requirement for the State of Kerala to withdraw its suit filed in the Supreme Court as a condition for granting additional borrowing consent. The bench, comprising Justices Surya Kant and KV Viswanathan, was hearing Kerala’s suit against the Union under Article 131 of the Constitution, challenging borrowing limits imposed by the Union.

During the hearing, the bench expressed dissatisfaction with the Union’s stance, questioning the validity of such a condition. It emphasized that while other conditions could be considered within constitutional parameters, the demand for withdrawal of the suit was unwarranted.

Addressing the Attorney General for India R Venkataramani and Additional Solicitor General N Venkataraman, Justice Surya Kant emphasized the importance of not imposing a condition that infringes upon the litigant’s constitutional right to file a suit.

Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal, representing Kerala, highlighted the urgency of the financial crisis faced by the State, urging for additional borrowing beyond the offered amount of Rs 13,608 crores.

The bench instructed both parties to hold discussions to resolve the issues, excluding the condition of withdrawing the suit. It acknowledged the need for a thorough examination of the constitutional issues raised in the suit, indicating that this case marks a precedent in its nature.

The suit revolves around the interpretation of Article 293 of the Constitution and the fiscal autonomy of states regarding borrowing. Kerala argues that its unique economic circumstances necessitate borrowing without Union consent to meet essential needs like education and health services.

The bench committed to a comprehensive examination of the issues raised, recognizing the gravity of the situation and its implications on the economy.

Ashish Sinha

-Ashish Kumar Sinha -Editor Legally Speaking -Ram Nath Goenka awardee - 14 Years of Experience in Media - Covering Courts Since 2008

Recent Posts

Supreme Court Says “Marriage Is Relationship Built On Mutual Trust, Companionship”

The Supreme Court has upheld a decision by the Madras High Court granting a divorce…

1 day ago

Delhi HC Grants Anticipatory Bail To Lawyer In Brother’s Criminal Case

The Delhi High Court has granted transit anticipatory bail to a lawyer whose brother is…

1 day ago

Justice Madan B Lokur Appointed As Chairperson of UN Internal Justice Council

Former Supreme Court Justice Madan B Lokur has been recently named the chairperson of the…

1 day ago

Karnataka High Court Directs NLSIU To Implement 0.5% Reservation For Transgender Persons

The Karnataka High Court has recently directed the National Law School of India University (NLSIU)…

2 days ago

Allahabad HC Directs UP Vigilance To Investigate Himalayan Cooperative Housing Land Issue

The Allahabad High Court has directed the Uttar Pradesh Vigilance Department to investigate the Himalayan…

2 days ago

Allahabad HC Grants Stay On Mohammed Zubair’s Arrest In Religious Enmity Case

The Allahabad High Court on Friday issued an order staying the arrest of Mohammed Zubair,…

2 days ago