Supreme Court Flags Alleged ‘Huge Racket’ In Tamil Nadu’s Fake Caste Certificate Scam

Supreme Court

The Supreme Court of India on Monday made a prima facie observation regarding the existence of a large-scale racket in Tamil Nadu facilitating the issuance of fraudulent caste certificates.

The court’s remarks emerged during proceedings related to numerous cases in which individuals were falsely certified as belonging to the Hindu Konda Reddis community, a Scheduled Tribe recognized under state law.

Widespread Issuance of Fraudulent Caste Certificates

The bench, comprising Justices J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan, expressed concern over the systematic nature of the scam, stating that while it was not making direct accusations at this stage, preliminary findings suggested a significant irregularity in the issuance of these certificates.

The Court underscored the gravity of the issue, given its implications for government benefits and reservations meant for genuine Scheduled Tribe members.

Judicial Directives and Investigation

To address the growing concern, the Supreme Court directed the Tamil Nadu government to conduct a thorough investigation through the State Level Scrutiny Committee. The Committee has been tasked with verifying the authenticity of these caste certificates and submitting a comprehensive report within 6 weeks.

The Court emphasized that this inquiry must be conducted in a fair, transparent, and impartial manner.

Case Review

One of the cases under review involved a woman who claimed Scheduled Tribe status for her son and sought an official caste certificate. However, her application was rejected following an inquiry by the Revenue Divisional Officer.

Subsequently, the Madras High Court ruled in her favor and directed the State Level Scrutiny Committee to examine her family’s caste status.

Challenging this decision, the Tamil Nadu government approached the Supreme Court, which had granted a temporary stay on the High Court’s order last year.

However, in a recent modification of its interim ruling, the Supreme Court permitted the verification of caste certificates while maintaining judicial oversight of the process.

Implications and Future Course of Action

The Supreme Court underscored the need to ascertain the legitimacy of thousands of caste certificates issued in the region, as well as to determine the mechanism through which such fraudulent certifications were allegedly obtained.

The court’s final decision will be based on the findings of the State Level Scrutiny Committee’s report, ensuring that due process is followed in addressing the alleged scam.

This development marks a crucial step in tackling systemic irregularities in caste certification, with significant implications for social justice and the integrity of reservation policies in India.